Reform scam FAQs

All FAQs | Customary Fisheries | Fisheries Management | maximum sustainable yield | QMS | Economics | Fishing | Rescue Fish | Environment | Fishing methods | Recreational Fishing | Fishcare | customary | Kahawai | Reform scam | Baitfish | Scallops | Crayfish | WRC decision | Marlin | Reef fish | Deemed value penalties | Judicial Review | Fisheries Amendment Bill 2026

Why do deemed value penalties exist?

February 19, 2026 Deemed value penalties are meant to work like a fine, a financial incentive that encourages fishers to stay within lawful catch limits. The penalty is supposed to be high enough to encourage responsible fishing, but low enough to discourage dumping of unwanted catch overboard.
Fisheries Management | QMS | Reform scam | Deemed value penalties

What are deemed value penalties?

February 19, 2026 Deemed value penalties are financial penalties commercial fishers are required to pay when they catch more fish than they are legally allowed.  Commercial fishers must acquire Annual Catch Entitlements (ACE) to cover the fish they catch. If they catch more fish than they have ACE, they must buy more ACE. If they cannot source enough ... Read more.
QMS | Reform scam | Deemed value penalties | Fisheries Management

Why is LegaSea calling the reforms a scam?

May 30, 2025 The Minister for Oceans and Fisheries is calling the proposed changes to the Fisheries Act a reform package, claiming that they will improve responsiveness, efficiency and certainty of how our fisheries are managed. The proposed changes are not real reforms. They are changes to give more control to commercial interests at the expense of the ... Read more.
Reform scam

How will the reforms benefit quota owners?

May 30, 2025 The “reforms” to the Fisheries Act will make it easier for quota owners to access and export our fish by reducing regulations, fast-tracking decisions and weakening sustainability safeguards. It also means quota owners can decide how much fish is caught during the year, a statutory function normally exercised by the Minister.
Reform scam

What impact will the proposed reforms have on my fishing?

May 30, 2025 They could have a big impact on recreational fishing and access to our most popular species. The proposals mean that commercial fishers get to determine how much fish is caught, where and when. The Minister is the only person with a statutory duty to limit catches and make sure there is enough fish in the ... Read more.
Reform scam

Who developed the proposed reforms?

May 30, 2025 Commercial fishing industry representatives spent a year developing a wishlist of changes. The Minister directed Fisheries New Zealand to work with the Seafood Industry Forum to develop a proposal package for public consultation. Recreational fishing and environmental representatives were deliberately not invited to participate in those discussions.
Reform scam

How will the proposed reforms impact the marine environment?

May 30, 2025 If successful some of the proposals will weaken environmental safeguards designed to protect the productivity and biodiversity of marine waters. These protection measures have been built up over many years after a lot of advocacy by recreational fishing organisations and other eNGOs. It will also mean less fish in the water. The proposals do not ... Read more.
Reform scam

Can we defeat the government’s proposed fisheries reforms?

May 30, 2025 Yes! Previous Ministers for Oceans and Fisheries have tried to introduce similar policies in the past but due to immense public backlash they have not succeeded.
Reform scam

What would real reform look like?

May 30, 2025 More fish in the water. Real reform is only possible if adequate governance and management structures are put in place. To get there we need to reform the whole Quota Management System. It is nearly 40 years old and still permits destructive fishing methods and overfishing.  The government must support commercial fishers to transition away ... Read more.
Rescue Fish | Reform scam

What are the next steps for the government’s reforms?

May 30, 2025 An Amendment Bill has been released. We expect the Bill will go before a Select Committee early this year. The public will only get to have a say at the Select Committee stage.  Our reality – the proposed changes could be locked into legislation by the end of 2026.
Reform scam